EDEN MAN ARRAIGNED FOR MENACING VICTIM AND VIOLATING ORDER OF PROTECTION

Remember that video Stefan Mychajliw and Republicans used to try and smear Erie County Clerk candidate Melissa Hartman?

Well it just came back to bite them in the ass as 48-year-old Luigi Palmieri of Eden was arraigned this morning before Hamburg Town Court Justice Gerald P. Gorman on one count of Menacing in the Second Degree and one count of Criminal Contempt in the Second Degree (Class “A” misdemeanors).

It is alleged that on Saturday, August 20, 2022, at approximately 11:28 p.m., the defendant yelled at a male victim outside on Hillbrook Drive while knowingly in violation of an order of protection issued on behalf of his family. It is further alleged that the victim’s wife and a male neighbor were walking along Hillbrook Drive when they encountered the defendant. The defendant was allegedly in possession of a large metal flashlight that he was shining toward the victims, which resulted in a verbal altercation. During the argument, the defendant allegedly approached while armed with the metal flashlight with the intent to place the victims in reasonable fear. The defendant was subsequently punched by the male neighbor.
An investigation determined that the male neighbor acted in self-defense. The defendant was later given an appearance ticket to be arraigned on the charge. The matter was transferred to Hamburg Town Court after both Eden Town Court Justices recused themselves from the case.
If convicted of the charges, Palmieri faces a maximum sentence of one year in jail. 
Palmieri has another pending criminal case that was transferred to Hamburg Town Court. He is charged with one count of Criminal Contempt in the First Degree (Class “E” felony). He is accused of repeatedly violating an order of protection, which placed the victim and her family in reasonable fear. The matter was transferred to Hamburg Town Court after both Eden Town Court Justices recused themselves from the case.
It is alleged that on October 27, 2021, at approximately 8:40 a.m., the victim saw the defendant, knowingly in violation of an existing order of protection, driving in the area of her place of employment. The victim allegedly saw the defendant driving past the building again as she entered Eden Town Hall.
It is alleged that on April 3, 2022, at approximately 5:25 p.m., the defendant drove slowly in his vehicle past the victim’s son as he was walking on Route 62 near Legion Drive in the Town of Eden. The defendant allegedly acted with no legitimate purpose while knowingly in violation of an existing order of protection.
It is alleged that on May 14, 2022, at approximately 6:35 p.m., the defendant drove slowly past the victim’s home in the Town of Eden as her children were playing outside. The defendant allegedly stopped his vehicle in front of the victim’s residence for no legitimate purpose while knowingly in violation of an existing order of protection.
It is also alleged that on July 13, 2022, at approximately 6:46 p.m., the defendant entered the victim’s place of employment, Eden Town Hall, during a board meeting while knowingly in violation of an existing order of protection. The defendant was asked to leave the building by an Eden Police officer. It is further alleged that at approximately at 9:25 p.m., the victim saw the defendant again inside of his vehicle in the parking lot as she exited the building.
The defendant was also previously charged in Eden Town Court with one count of Reckless Endangerment in the Second Degree (Class “A” misdemeanor), one count of Harassment in the Second Degree and one count of Unlawfully Dealing with Fireworks and Dangerous Fireworks (violations). He was arraigned on July 4, 2021. The case was adjourned in contemplation of dismissal on January 4, 2022. An order of protection was issued on behalf of the victim and her family.
The defendant is accused of intentionally detonating a firework near the victim and her husband, which created a substantial risk of serious physical injury. The alleged incident occurred on Hillbrook Drive in the Town of Eden on Friday, July 2, 2021.
Due to the recent charges and alleged violation of the order of protection, the case has been restored to the active calendar in Hamburg Town Court.
Palmieri is scheduled to return to Hamburg Town Court on Tuesday, December 6, 2022 at 9:00 a.m. for a pre-trial conference on all cases. He remains released on his own recognizance.
A no-contact order of protection remains in place on behalf of the victim and her family.
DA Flynn commends the Eden Police Department and the Erie County Sheriff’s Office for their work in these investigations.
Both cases are being prosecuted by Assistant District Attorney William Fitzgerald of the Felony Trials Bureau and Assistant District Attorney Stephen C. Papia of the Justice Courts Bureau.

Related articles

Hochul promotes her agenda with state-funded ad campaign

Gov. Kathy Hochul does not appear in the ads directly though it encourages people to visit a New York run website touting her accomplishments towards more affordable housing.

HOCHUL’S AD CAMPAIGN: Gov. Kathy Hochul’s office is using taxpayer money to fund an advertising blitz promoting her agenda, brushing up against a ban on governors appearing in promotional material.

State law prohibits elected officials from appearing in ads paid for with state funds.

Hochul doesn’t directly appear in any of the ads. Instead, they encourage people to visit a state-run website where she’s prominently featured talking about wanting to cut red tape to build affordable housing.

“They’re skirting the very intent of what that law was meant to do, and that’s using taxpayer dollars to promote the image or likeness of the governor,” Republican Assemblymember Matt Slater said. “It’s clearly something that needs to be looked into so we can figure out what consequences she should be facing if she is in fact violating the law.”

The ads have appeared over the past week on Facebook, YouTube, and at least one billboard. The governor’s office said a FOIL request would be required to see the full scope.

One example is a YouTube commercial that simply states “Let Them Build” and directs people to the state’s website. The Executive Chamber has spent between $10,000 and $15,000 on that ad — one of 21 to air on YouTube or Google over the past week. The ad has been viewed one million times.

"The state routinely engages in awareness and education campaigns on critical policy priorities and this campaign was designed in compliance with all ethics laws,” said Hochul spokesperson Jen Goodman.

Reinvent Albany’s Rachael Fauss said that if the 20-year-old law had been written today, “it probably would take into consideration” campaigns like this.

“From a technical perspective, she may not be violating the law,” she said. “But I think the spirit of the law is to not have the governor’s likeness be promoted through the use of taxpayer funds. That was the intent of it. Unfortunately, this is an area where the law hasn’t kept up with the way people consume media and ads these days.”

The ban on advertising came about after former Gov. George Pataki ran state-funded commercials during an election year in which he encouraged people to register in a new healthcare program. Ethics reforms passed as part of former Gov. Eliot Spitzer’s inaugural agenda included language prohibiting the practice.

Hochul isn’t the first elected official to brush up against the intent of the law in recent months. New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s likeness has appeared on WiFi kiosks, a practice that’s permitted since the city is given the screentime for free. And Mamdani, unlike Hochul, isn’t up for reelection anytime soon.

“She’s got plenty of campaign funds that she could be using to pay for these things,” Slater said. “What she’s doing right now is spending taxpayer money to enhance her image when she’s on the ballot this year.” — Bill Mahoney

FROM THE CAPITOL

Attorney General Letitia James appeared in Albany this morning to support regulating algorithmic pricing legislation.

PRICING POLITICS: Democratic state Attorney General Letitia James is throwing her support behind a bill meant to crack down on retailers’ use of algorithmic pricing.

James was in Albany this morning to back legislation meant to halt the practice, which uses a consumer’s personal data to set individually tailored prices.

The bill, backed by Assemblymember Michaelle Solages and Deputy Senate Majority Leader Mike Gianaris, is part of a broader push being made by elected officials to address peoples’ pocketbook concerns.

“This online pricing model hits hardest where it hurts the most — food, medicine, diapers and other essentials,” James said at a news conference. “We all have all been focused on the issue of affordability across this state.” Nick Reisman

FROM CITY HALL

Former NYPD sergeant Tim Pearson (third from left) served as a top mayoral aide to former Mayor Eric Adams.

EVIDENCE HUNT: The former NYPD sergeant accusing former mayoral aide Tim Pearson of sexual harassment wants to get her hands on the evidence that prompted the Mamdani administration to stop paying for Pearson’s legal bills.

In 2024, the former sergeant, Roxanne Ludemann, sued Pearson, a confidant and top adviser to former Mayor Eric Adams, accusing him of sexually harassing her at work and then professionally retaliating against her when she rejected his overtures.

Thanks to an unusual arrangement greenlit by Adams’ Law Department, Pearson received taxpayer-funded private lawyers to defend him against Ludemann’s suit. But Mamdani’s corporation counsel, Steve Banks, announced last week that he had rescinded Pearson’s arrangement, citing unspecified “new evidence” that warranted terminating it.

In a court filing late Friday, John Scola, an attorney representing Ludemann, demanded that the Law Department provide his client with access to the evidence in question, arguing it’s relevant to her ongoing case.

“Produce all documents, records, evidence, reports, memoranda, and materials of any kind that constitute, refer to, or relate to the ‘new evidence’ relied upon, reviewed, considered, or referenced by corp counsel in making its determination to decline or withdraw representation of Defendant Timothy Pearson in this matter,” Scola wrote in the filing.

Also last week, Banks terminated a similar arrangement that allowed Jeffrey Maddrey, an Adams ally and former NYPD chief of department, to receive taxpayer-funded attorneys in the Pearson matter, too. Maddrey is accused by Ludemann of helping Pearson retaliate against her.

Scola’s filing demanded access to the information that prompted Banks to slash Maddrey’s arrangement as well.

Pearson and Maddrey, who resigned from city government in late 2024 after being ensnared in unrelated corruption investigations, have denied any wrongdoing.

A Law Department spokesperson did not comment when asked today about Scola’s demand.

New York City taxpayers have already paid more than $620,000 to cover Pearson’s legal tab alone. — Chris Sommerfeldt


FINANCE SHUFFLE: Mamdani is zeroing in on a pick to run the Department of Finance, a normally under-the-radar agency that has taken on new prominence amid the mayor’s push to raise property taxes.

Mamdani’s administration is in talks to hire Richard Lee for the job, according to three people with knowledge of the discussions who were granted anonymity to discuss an internal personnel matter.

Lee currently serves as director of the City Council’s Division of Finance. That means his move to Mamdani’s finance department would leave Council Speaker Julie Menin without her top budget adviser amid increasingly tense negotiations over the city’s $127 billion spending plan for the upcoming fiscal year.

The Council is conducting budget oversight hearings throughout the month to better ascertain how city agencies are planning to operate amid a precarious fiscal situation. The city is facing a projected multi-billion dollar deficit over the next fiscal year, and Mamdani’s administration is relying on cash reserves, optimistic revenue projections and an increase in property taxes to bridge that gap and balance the spending plan for the fiscal year beginning July 1.

Increasing levies on property owners would require approval from the Council, and Menin has dismissed the idea as a nonstarter. She has argued the city needs to look for other ways to cut costs beforehand. The mayor, by contrast, says drastic steps like property levy hikes can be avoided if Albany gives the city the authority to raise local taxes on millionaires and corporations — proposals Menin has declined to support.

Lee, should he ultimately join Mamdani’s administration, would be working for the finance department as it tabulates a key variable — the assessed value of property in New York City — which helps determine how much revenue the city collects from owners each year.

Read the story from Joe Anuta and Chris Sommerfeldt in POLITICO Pro

AROUND NEW YORK

MACHIAVELLIAN MAMDANI: The mayor forced his political will on fellow lefty lawmakers, including by squashing Tiffany Cabán’s congressional prospects and threatening Chi Ossé. (The New York Times)

ADAMS OFFICIAL UNDER PROBE: The former commissioner of the city’s probation department under Mayor Eric Adams is being investigated by the Manhattan district attorney. (Gothamist)

MAYOR DINES WITH KNICKS: Mamdani broke his Saturday Ramadan fast with Senegalese Knicks player Mo Diawara. (GQ)

Missed this morning’s New York Playbook? We forgive you. Read it here.

Another Buffalo cop cited for misconduct

Buffalo Police Officer Calvis McKnight (right). Photo: Buffalo Police...