Italian Americans Railing Against New Wave of Migrants Need a Lesson in History

The mindless ignorant $hit coming from the @WBEN airwaves this morning was absolutely disgusting. Here’s a taste from their Italian American “Medal of Honor” recipient host:

If David Bellavia and WBEN think their Italian ancestors came to the US with a law degree or medical license in hand, they are a lot dumber than they look.

Most Italians who migrated to this country in the late 19th and early 20th century did so like many who come here today. With literally nothing. And if they showed up before 1921 like most of our ancestors there were practically ZERO laws or requirements for them to abide by.

The reasons Italians migrated to the United States in the late 19th and early 20th centuries are strikingly similar to the reasons new wave of migrants are coming to the US today:

  • Poverty: Italy was a poor country in the late 19th century, and many Italians were struggling to make ends meet. The United States, on the other hand, was seen as a land of opportunity, where people could come to start a new life and make a better living.
  • Unemployment: Unemployment was high in Italy, and many people were unable to find work. The United States, on the other hand, was experiencing a period of economic growth, and there was a demand for labor.
  • Political unrest: Italy was a politically unstable country in the late 19th century. There were frequent uprisings and revolutions, and many people felt that they could not live in peace in Italy. The United States, on the other hand, was seen as a stable and democratic country.
  • Natural disasters: Italy was hit by a number of natural disasters in the late 19th century, including earthquakes, floods, and famines. These disasters displaced many people and made it difficult to make a living. The United States, on the other hand, was seen as a safe haven from natural disasters.

Many of the people who came here under terrible distress and horrible conditions, ended up making significant contributions to American society in a variety of fields, including business, agriculture, and the arts. the list is long.

But they certainly didn’t come here making $250k a year or get off the boat and buy houses on millionaires’ row upon their arrival to #Buffalo

Most lived in tenement slums in a neighborhood called “the hooks”

Former brothels and hotels for canal workers and travelers became tenements.  These three and four story brick buildings housing multiple families in crowded conditions. The tenements were poorly-ventilated, small rooms with little heat, frozen pipes in winter and little sunlight. Cholera and pneumonia were common in the tenements.  Many of the immigrants lived in poverty. Rooms rented for $6/month (about $100-130 in current dollars).  In 1890, one old hotel called the Revere Block, originally designed to hold 100 guests, had 1,040 residents living in crammed conditions.  Reports in other buildings included 18 families crammed into four rooms; 56 people sharing eight bedrooms.  Conditions in many of these tenements were disgusting and unsanitary. Social work organizations began working to help deal with the conditions in the district.  Charity Organization Society and Miss Maria Love began to work with the churches around 1895, working to organize efforts against poverty throughout the City of Buffalo.   Seventy-six churches, of 12 denominations, pitched in to help around the city.  Each church was responsible for a district, working for the “moral elevation of the people, and for the relief of all the needy and neglected persons of whatever religious faith within the district”.

Most were unskilled, uneducated laborers who worked any job they could find in #Buffalo until they could better their lot in life.

Similar to the a$$holes we see and hear on places like WBEN, our migrant ancestors were met with much of the same hatred from local newspapers and media that people like David Bellavia and other WBEN hosts spew regularly on local radio.

Here’s a clip from our 2007 documentary “La Terra Promessa” that tells some of the struggles Italians faced when coming to this country in the late 19th and early 20th Century.

The context of the video was taken from a Buffalo newspaper article published on May 24th, 1891. Almost 131 years to the day:

So yeah, people (particularly Italian Americans like Bellavia) who continue to stereotype today’s asylum seekers and migrants for wanting a better life for themselves and their families is not only repugnant. It’s shameful.

If you don’t think your Irish, Polish or German ancestors had similar challenges to the migrants of today, you really should check your own history as well.

Related articles

Your Windows Are About to Close for the Winter. What Are You Breathing? 

by Annette Pinder  Before you know it, cooler weather will...

‘Chaos’ at Trump’s ‘mega master’ court renders judges and defendants ‘terrified’: Report



The Trump administration's newly launched "mega master" court system has quickly devolved into mass chaos that leaves defendants, guards, lawyers and judges "terrified," according to a new report.

"Attorneys and former judges say mega master hearings serve as the latest tool for the Trump administration to deport large numbers of people," the Chicago Sun-Times reported Friday. "This time by causing chaos and confusion in the courts."

Courtroom 11 at Chicago's immigration court barely seats 25 people — but one July morning saw 60 people, mostly unrepresented asylum seekers, crammed in wall-to-wall by 9:10 a.m., the Sun-Times reported.

This is a "mega master" calendar hearing, a new procedural format instituted by the Trump administration at the end of May that packs between 100 and 185 people into a single judge's morning docket — up from an average of just 30 before the change.

Chicago's courthouse at 55 E. Monroe has logged more of these mass hearings than any other immigration court in the country, according to immigration scholar Austin Kocher.

The scale has created conditions former immigration judges call dangerous.

On days when multiple mega hearings are scheduled simultaneously, hundreds of people — including families with strollers — spill into hallways narrower than an adult's arm span, waiting for hours to be called.

On one recent Thursday, roughly 200 people queued in the heat outside courtrooms designed to hold a fraction of that number.

"This is not good," one guard was overheard saying. Former judges have raised concerns that the overcrowded hallways amount to a fire hazard.

Attorneys and former judges argue the hearings serve to discourage immigrants from showing up at all, then fast-tracking deportations for those who don't.

In June, for the first time since 2019, more immigrants missed their Chicago court dates than attended — 58 percent of the 10,370 people summoned nationwide in June were marked absent, according to data from the nonprofit Mobile Pathways. Missing court can trigger an automatic in absentia deportation order.

Compounding the pressure, notice periods have collapsed. Median lead time for a Chicago hearing fell to just 34 days in June, down from 229 days in May.

The Justice Department, which oversees immigration courts, says the expanded scheduling is meant to clear long-standing backlogs.

But former judge Elizabeth Treacy, who resigned in June after presiding over three mega hearings with up to 150 people each, said the volume makes errors — and injustice — nearly inevitable.

She noted that indigenous asylum seekers with limited Spanish fluency are especially unlikely to speak up when they don't understand proceedings in a crowded, intimidating room.

“It’s not a coincidence, but another tactic to facilitate deportations,” said Stephanie Spiro, an attorney with the National immigration Justice Center.

“It’s much more efficient for the government to deport people without even having to read any briefs, without having to have a full hearing, without having to schedule hundreds of people, and actually listen to their claims, and afford them due process.”

That fear caused Carolina, an immigrant from Venezuela who just gave birth, to question whether she should show up for her hearing.

She and her husband eventually decided to risk deportation and bring their three children to court.

“I was terrified," she said.

Baseless claim Natalie Harp is Trump’s hospice nurse spreads online

President Donald Trump's executive assistant has been nicknamed "the human printer."