Judge Ruled Emergency Orders Barring Asylum-Seekers Unconstitutional

New York City Mayor Eric Adams announced the city is filing a lawsuit against 30 other New York counties over executive orders that aim to prevent New York City from sending asylum-seekers to their counties. Included in the lawsuit are Chautauqua, Niagara, Orleans and Genesee Counties.
Earlier this week, a federal court ruling suspended emergency orders from two county executives barring the transportation and housing of asylum-seekers in hotels and other lodging outside of New York City.
District Court Judge Nelson S. Roman stated that the emergency orders issued in Rockland and Orange counties were fundamentally discriminatory and violated the federal civil and constitutional rights of migrants and asylum-seekers. ‘
The judge’s order only grants a preliminary injunction allowing asylum-seekers to be housed in Rockland and Orange counties. While Roman’s ruling does not technically interfere with other county emergency orders or temporary restraining orders granted in state courts, the federal decision does appear to highlight major legal hurdles that county leaders would have to overcome if they intend to defend their issued states of emergency and fight future legal challenges.

 

At least 30 counties in the state have issued emergency declarations and executive orders barring sheltering migrants; four counties, including Rockland, Orange, Dutchess and Onondaga counties, have filed lawsuits against the city; and towns have filed suits against hotels.

Named as defedants in the suit are:

  • Rockland County and Executive Ed Day
  • Orange County and Executive Steve Neuhaus
  • Dutchess County and Executive William O’Neil
  • Onondaga County and Executive Ryan McMahon
  • Broome County and Executive Jason Garnar
  • Cayuga County and Legislature Chairman David Gould
  • Chautauqua County and Executive Paul Wendel Jr.
  • Cheming County and Executive Chris Moss
  • Cortland County and Legislaure Chair Kevin Fitch
  • Delaware County and Board of Supervisors Chair Tina Mole
  • Fulton County and Board of Supervisors Chair Scott Horton
  • Genesee County and Manager L. Matthew Landers
  • Greene County and Legislature Chair Patrick Linger
  • Herkimer County and Legislature Chair Vincent Bono
  • Madison County and Board of Supervisors Chair John Becker
  • Niagara County and Legislature Chair Rebecca Wydysh
  • Oneida County and Executive Anthony Picente
  • Orleans County and Legislature Chair Lynne Johnson
  • Oswego County and Legislature Chairman James Weatherup
  • Otsego County and board Chairman David Bliss
  • Putnam County and Executive Kevin Byrne
  • Rensselaer County and Executive Steve McLaughlin
  • Town of Riverhead and Supervisor Yvette Aguiar
  • Saratoga County and Board of Supervisors Chair Ted Kusnierz
  • Schoharie County and Board of Supervisors Chair William Federice
  • Schuyler County and Legislature Chair Carl Blowers
  • Suffolk County and Executive Steve Bellone
  • Sullivan County and Manager Joshua Potosek
  • Tioga County and Legislature Chair Martha Sauerbrey
  • Warren County Board of Supervisors Chair Kevin Geraghty
  • Wyoming County and Board of Supervisors Chair Rebecca Ryan

Erie County Executive Mark Poloncarz refused to sign a declaration despite pressure from Erie County Republicans to do so.

“The court confirmed what I already knew was the case: the emergency orders were illegal under federal equal protection and civil rights laws,” said Erie County Executive Mark Poloncarz.

“Our laws are very clear, and no one, including a government, can discriminate against another when it comes to public accommodations, no matter the reason given.”

Loader Loading...
EAD Logo Taking too long?

Reload Reload document
| Open Open in new tab

Related articles

D’Youville University Receives Candidacy for Speech-Language Pathology Program

  Buffalo, New York – July 18, 2024: D’Youville University...

‘Never heard anything so ridiculous’: Lawmaker mocked over effort to impeach Kamala Harris



Rep. Andy Ogles (R-TN) introduced articles of impeachment against Vice President Kamala Harris on Tuesday, following a House GOP caucus meeting in which members frantically strategized over how to stop momentum for Harris' newly kicked-off presidential campaign.

The impeachment articles proclaim that Harris has committed high crimes and misdemeanors through "incompetence" in her role as "border czar" (a position she has never actually had) and then proceed to cite several anecdotes of women killed by unauthorized migrants, as well as the fact that over 50 million fentanyl pills were seized by DEA in 2022 (even though seizures indicate the law is being enforced, and even though most of it is seized during border crossings at checkpoints, often from U.S. citizens.)

Nowhere in the resolution does it list a purported act of misconduct or abuse of power by Harris — something that was noticed by commenters on social media who roundly ridiculed the measure.

Read also: AOC introduces impeachment resolutions against Justices Alito and Thomas

"Ogles claims in this resolution that Harris is the 'designated border czar,' a nonexistent position that Biden did not name her to," wrote immigration law expert Aaron Reichlin-Melnick, providing a link to the White House announcement on the subject. "Here is the primary source. Biden is clear that Harris agreed to lead the admin's diplomatic 'root causes' strategy only."

"These idiots need a new bag of tricks. This is so tiresome," wrote "Mrs. Betty Bowers," the satirical Christian fundamentalist persona of Canadian comedian Deven Green.

"What a stupid move," wrote the account @TisMoreorLess.

"This is great in that it shows just how panicked they are," wrote the account @SundaeDivine.

"I've never heard anything so ridiculous," wrote the account @sandiechill.

"They have nothing except their own embarrassment at this point," wrote the account @J_Pauselius.

"The Republican party is the political retribution party. They've done nothing for the American people," wrote the account @DenisonBarbs.

Ogles, who has come under fire for embellishing his political resume before being elected and has faced an ethics complaint over his campaign finances, is no stranger to pushing politically charged show bills. Last month, he vowed to introduce a "No Juicing Joe" bill that would have required President Joe Biden to disclose whenever he takes a "mind-altering stimulant."

Read excerpts of the impeachment resolution below or at the link here.

RNSM at Larkinville

The post RNSM at Larkinville appeared...

The Trump Campaign Is Lowering Expectations

Former President Donald Trump’s campaign team apparently believes we are experiencing a vibe shift. On Tuesday afternoon, the Trump campaign...

‘Grasping’: Obama’s ex-campaign manager laughs that Trump team caught off guard by Biden



Republicans are scrambling to regain their footing after President Joe Biden dropped his re-election campaign and threw his support behind Vice President Kamala Harris.

The 81-year-old president ended his campaign Sunday following weeks of mounting pressure from other Democrats over concerns about his age, and Barack Obama's former campaign manager David Plouffe told MSNBC's "Morning Joe" that Donald Trump and his GOP allies were left grasping at straws following the shakeup.

"I've been impressed by Kamala's interviews the last few weeks," Plouffe said. "She's a prosecutor, he's a criminal – I like the matchup.

"Listen, let's not forget, the biggest issue in this campaign was Joe Biden's age. If Donald Trump gets elected, he'll be older than Joe Biden [was] on Inauguration Day. This guy is showing serious signs of unfitness — yes, in terms of character and the positions he holds, but in terms of his decline. He is really, really having trouble reading the Teleprompter. Obviously, the [Republican National Convention] speech was bad in tone, but he couldn't follow instructions there. This should give us great pause."

ALSO READ: 'You babbling baboon': Nonsensical Trump post spurs Truth Social taunts

The former president had been counting on a rematch with his 2020 rival, and although his team has been preparing for the possibility that Biden would drop out, Plouffe made fun of Trump adviser Jason Miller for coming out of the chute by attacking Harris for supporting a ban on plastic straws for environmental reasons.

"I'm excited about this," Plouffe said. "I think the Trump campaign doesn't seem like they were as prepared for this switch as perhaps they might have been. They seem like they're kind of grasping. I guess they're talking about plastic straws and whatnot – not a compelling message."

Watch the video below or at this link.

MSNBC 07 22 2024 07 17 29 youtu.be