Schumer Asks FTC to Investigate Unauthorized Copying and Distribution of Private Information

Senator Charles E. Schumer has called for the Federal Trade Commission to launch an investigation into reports that smartphone applications sold on the Apple and Android platforms are allowed to steal private photos and customers address books.

This past week, the New York Times revealed that iPhone and Android applications downloaded by users can actually gain access to a customer’s private photo collection, and in some cases share the information online. This latest report comes on the heels of the discovery last month that applications on Apple devices like the iPhone and iPad were able to upload entire address books with names, phone numbers, and email address to their own servers. In both cases, users were not notified that their private information stored on their phone and or iPad could be copied and used by third party applications.

“When someone takes a private photo, on a private cell phone, it should remain just that: private,” said Schumer. “Smartphone developers have an obligation to protect the private content of their users and not allow them to be veritable treasure troves of private, personal information that can then be uploaded and distributed without the consumer’s consent.”

According to reports by independent technologists, two separate loopholes, one in the Apple operating system and one in the Android operating system, allow apps to gather users’ photos. In the case of Apple, if a user allows the application to use location data, which is used for GPS-based applications, they also allow access to the user’s photo and video files that can be uploaded to outside servers. In the case of Android-based applications, the user only needs to allow the application to use Internet services as part of the app for third parties to gain access to photo albums.

“It sends shivers up the spine to think that one’s personal photos, address book, and who-knows-what-else can be obtained and even posted online – without consent. If the technology exists to open the door to this kind of privacy invasion, then surely technology exists to close it, and that’s exactly what must happen. The rapid innovation in technology, which is wonderful, must not also become an open invitation to violate people’s privacy willy-nilly. When a consumer makes a private phone call or sends a letter the old fashioned way, they have a very reasonable expectation that the communication is private. The same standard must apply to our new technologies, too,” continued Schumer.

Two weeks ago it was revealed that some of the most popular applications for smart phones were routinely collecting personal data from users’ address books, despite policies in place from smartphone makers like Apple that explicitly prohibit such action without the prior consent of the user. After reports revealed this widespread practice, several applications announced they would end the practice. Questions remain, however, over the implementation of security policies employed by smartphone manufacturers and their oversight of applications sold on their platforms.

Schumer today, in a letter to the Federal Trade Commission, called for the agency to launch a comprehensive investigation to explicitly determine whether copying or distributing personal information from smartphones, without a user’s consent, constitutes an unfair or deceptive trade practice. Schumer is also urging the agency to require smart phone makers put in place safety measures to ensure third party applications are not able to violate a user’s personal privacy by stealing photographs or data that the user did not consciously decide to make public.

Related articles

The Strangest Presidential Election Year We’ve Ever Endured

A lot of things happened. Here are some of the things. This is TPM’s Morning Memo. Sign up for the...

X posts – Photo does not show pro-Palestine protesters blocking Jewish students from entering Columbia Univers

Photo shows “Palestinian activists” blocking “Jewish students from entering Columbia University.”

Peering into the Corrupt Court’s Pretensions and Corruption

There were so many things that happened yesterday in the Supreme Court’s hearing on presidential immunity that it’s hard to...

‘Extreme position’: Democrats hit back as MTG blasts alliance with Mike Johnson



WASHINGTON — Reps. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA) and Tom Massie (R-KY) announced on Wednesday from the U.S. Capitol that they will continue to file a motion to remove Speaker Mike Johnson (R-LA) from his post.

Massie told reporters that Johnson aligned himself with Democratic votes on the omnibus spending bill, Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) reauthorization, and the national security bill that funded Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan military aid.

He and Greene characterized them as the three "betrayals" to the GOP.

The votes passed with overwhelming support from Democrats along with several Republicans.

"He is a lost ball in tall weeds. ... He's in over his head," Massie said about Johnson, according to Jake Sherman at Punchbowl News.

Johnson was voted in after former Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) was removed by members of his own party. Before Johnson was chosen, nearly 20 votes were cast for other candidates for the new speaker.

House Democratic Whip Katherine Clark (MA) told Raw Story she wasn't aware of the know what the intention of the far-right flank of the House Republicans.

ALSO READ: ‘Clear indication’: Dems accuse GOP congressional candidate of illegal super PAC ties

She disputed Greene's claim that the Democrats were a "uniparty" united with Johnson after her party's leaders declared Tuesday that they would vote to table any motion to remove him from Greene.

"We are not a party that is endorsing Donald Trump; that is moved to the most extreme position in opposition to what the American people want us to do here," said Clark. "So, our goal here is to get back to governing. And this particular motion to vacate — we will table. But that is not a statement of unity with anything this House GOP is doing."

Rep. Ted Lieu (D-CA) agreed, saying that Democrats were certainly not aligned with the MAGA Republicans.

"Donald Trump Republicans campaign on overturning Roe v. Wade. Republicans overturn Roe v. Wade. Donald Trump bragged about it," Lieu told Raw Story as a way of contrasting the two parties.

He explained that if the Democrats flip the House and keep the Senate, they will pass legislation that would codify reproductive healthcare rights in American law.

"So, the two parties are clearly not the same," Lieu continued. "Marjorie Taylor Greene can make up whatever she wants. But to say that somehow the two parties are the same is factually wrong."

He agreed with Democratic Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (NY), who said that the caucus would vote to table the motion to vacate Johnson from the speakership.

Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-IL) confirmed that it likely "won't take that many Democrats" to table the motion and ultimately save Johnson.

"Do we want to wait another three weeks, maybe a month, to find another speaker? Who the hell is that going to be?" she said to Raw Story.

"I don't think anyone wants it. I don't think there are the votes for it," she continued. "So, we'll have another period of completely dysfunctional government."

Adams talks protest busting

With help from Shawn Ness

New from New York

Happening now:

  • Mayor Eric Adams talked about the reasons why it was time to break up the protests on college campuses.
  • New York has a new secretary of state that will need state Senate approval.
  • New York City's budget is getting bigger and bigger.
  • Why Attorney General Tish James and her colleagues are suing the NCAA.
Mayor Eric Adams this morning showed reporters a chain that was used to barricade a door during college protests in New York City.

DEMS DEFEND CAMPUS CRACKDOWN: The police were not just arresting pro-Palestinian protesters at Manhattan colleges Tuesday night, but protecting “children” from “outside agitators,” Mayor Eric Adams said, defending the NYPD in a round of media appearances this morning.

“This is a global problem, that young people are being influenced by those who are professionals at radicalizing our children,” Adams said at a press conference with police Wednesday morning. “And I’m not going to let that happen as the mayor of the city of New York.”

Adams declined to elaborate on who the agitators were. And while it’s not in question that some of the people protesting at campuses were not students, the NYPD’s main evidence today — that protesters who seized a building used thick bike locks favored by students — was roundly mocked online.

The police actions were the largest mobilizations yet of New York City police in response to recent pro-Palestinian protests on college campuses. Adams emphasized that Columbia University and City College both formally requested the NYPD’s help responding. Protesters at Columbia had seized and barricaded an academic building on campus, and City College, they set up tents and occupied a main lawn on campus.

The NYPD said 173 people were arrested at City College, and 109 were arrested at Columbia on Tuesday night.

Leading Democrats, including Gov. Kathy Hochul and House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, backed up the high profile police responses.

"As far as I can tell, the efforts by the NYPD were thorough, professional, and they exercised the degree of calm in a very tense situation that should be commended,” Jeffries said at a press conference today, POLITICO’s Nicholas Wu reported.

“The rest of the campus, they should not be living in fear because you're claiming an exercise of your rights,” Hochul said at a separate media availability. “But that's what was starting to happen on our campuses over the last couple of weeks.”

But New York Civil Liberties Union Executive Director Donna Lieberman said reports of police closing blocks of the city, pepper spraying protesters and throwing them to the ground showed the response was “counterproductive and downright dangerous.”

“While other campuses across the country have engaged demonstrators in productive dialogue, at Columbia and City College last night the NYPD responded instead with intimidation and violence. — Jeff Coltin

Former Assemblymember Walter Mosley was picked by Gov. Kathy Hochul to be the next secretary of state. He now awaits Senate confirmation.

SENDING OUT AN SOS: Former Assemblymember Walter Mosley is Hochul’s choice to become the next secretary of state for New York, her office announced today.

“The Department of State plays a critical role implementing a broad array of government services, from the Downtown Revitalization Initiative to the Office for New Americans,” Hochul said in a statement.

“Walter Mosley’s public service in the New York State Assembly and his years of leadership in his community have given him the skills and experience necessary to lead this Department into the future.”

The Democratic assemblymember represented Brooklyn in the Assembly from 2013 to 2021 and lost a primary to Phara Souffrant Forrest.

If confirmed by the state Senate, Mosley would replace Robert Rodriguez in the post. Rodriguez was nominated last month to become the president and CEO of the state Dormitory Authority.

I am deeply honored to be chosen by Governor Hochul to serve as Secretary of State,” Mosley said. “My career has been focused on finding ways to make government work for the people, and I am thrilled to take on this pivotal role in state government.” Nick Reisman

The Citizens Budget Commission released a new report showing how much New York City's spending has increased since 2020.

BUDGET WATCHERS: The Citizens Budget Commission wants to remind New York City residents just how much the Adams administration has been spending.

The budget for the fiscal year beginning July 1 is on track to increase city spending by more than 6 percent compared to the current year, according to a report from the business-backed fiscal watchdog.

The increase would be even more pronounced if around $2.2 billion for programs the city is likely to spend money on — but have not been included in the plan — is factored into the equation.

The growth is part of a broader trend. Between 2020 and this summer, the city’s spending is projected to balloon 26 percent, outpacing inflation by more than 43 percent.

And even if migrant spending were excluded, spending growth would still be up 21 percent over the same time period, roughly $15 billion, the report found. — Shawn Ness

A new report found that only 12 percent of registered voters in New York City voted in the last primary and general elections.

ELECTION TURNOUT TROUBLES: Less than 13 percent of registered voters in New York City participated in the elections, according to a new report from the New York City Campaign Finance Board.

To increase turnout, the report recommends two policies: one that would host local elections in even numbered years, and another that would create a civic engagement fellowship program to expand voter outreach programs.

New York has a law on the books that will move most local elections to even numbers years to correlate with state and federal races, but it doesn't apply to New York City and is facing legal challenges.

The goal, Democrats say, is to increase voter turnout, but Republicans contend it's a way for Democrats in party to further hurt the GOP in a state with twice as many Democrats than Republicans.

“New York City’s democracy is only as strong as the share of the city that participates. Even with 82 percent of eligible New Yorkers registered to vote, we have a long way to go until voting and full civic participation are accessible to every single New Yorker,” Paul Ryan, the executive director of the board, said in a statement.

In the two most recent elections in the city, only seven percent of voters participated in the primary and 12.8 percent in the general election, despite 81 percent of eligible voters being registered, the group said. — Shawn Ness 

JAMES SUES NCAA: The state Attorney General's Office is joining efforts with a multistate coalition to sue the NCAA for policies that prevent student athletes from earning money and benefits from their “name, image and likeliness.”

Attorney General Tish James said the policy prevents student athletes from looking at compensation offers before enrolling at a school, which keeps them from fully understanding their options before deciding where to go for college. Other states listed on the lawsuit include Tennessee, Florida, District of Columbia and Virginia.

“New York student athletes are some of the best in the country, and they should be able to make decisions about their athletic career without restrictions,” Attorney General Letitia James said in a statement.

“The NCAA’s NIL rule limits college athletes’ potential and restricts competition among universities — that’s not fair game. Student athletes should be able to call the shots on their career fairly and evenly.” — Katelyn Cordero 

On the campaign trail

Micah Lasher is running for Assembly in the 69th district.

HOCHUL FUNDRAISING FOR LASHER: Hochul will attend a swanky fundraiser for Upper West Side Assembly candidate Micah Lasher tonight. The affair is being hosted by Dan Doctoroff, a former deputy mayor under Michael Bloomberg and former CEO of Bloomberg L.P.

Lasher was previously Hochul’s top policy adviser and worked for Bloomberg earlier in his career. He faces a four-way primary, with public defender Eli Northrup, a Working Families Party candidate, likely to be his most formidable challenger.

The 69th District seat, which includes the embattled Columbia University, is currently held by Assemblymember Danny O’Donnell. He is retiring after representing the area for 20 years. While other big names like Rep. Jerry Nadler, Manhattan Borough President Mark Levine and former NYC Comptroller Scott Stringer have endorsed Lasher, O’Donnell still hasn’t announced support for a candidate in the race.

While O’Donnell has shied away from commenting on Columbia’s protests, Lasher commented on the unrest in a statement to Playbook.

“The situation has been heart-breaking in so many ways,” he said. “At this point I only hope that the Columbia community can find a way forward.”

Earlier today, Northrup called the deploying of the NYPD Tuesday evening a “wholly disproportionate response.”

The tickets to attend the 6:30 pm fundraiser range from $1,000 to $3,000.

“I couldn’t be more honored to have two of my former bosses, Dan Doctoroff and Governor Hochul, along with Alisa Doctoroff, teaming up to give our campaign a boost as we enter the home stretch,” Lasher said in a separate statement.

Northrup blasted Lasher for the fundraiser.

“My opponent is clearly ideologically aligned with our governor and will continue to be influenced by big money and special interests, rather than being accountable to our community,” Northrup said. “We need elected officials that work with and for the people — not career politicians who are disconnected from the issues we're facing." Jason Beeferman

— Protesters gathered outside NYPD headquarters after they arrested nearly 300 protesters at Columbia University and CUNY College Tuesday evening. (State of Politics)

The Department of Investigations probe of an Adams adviser is now expanding to include his role with NYPD personnel and promotional matters. (Daily News)

— Students at SUNY Stony Brook’s encampment were warned they might have to move to another location. (Newsday)